Mourning Michigan: Part II

April 14, 2009 / 2:35 pm • By Dr. Melissa Clouthier

After visiting Michigan, my home state, this last summer, I wrote an emotional post expressing my grief at how the state has declined. It is still difficult to contemplate, because the place is so dear to me.

You can understand why, then, this article from the Detroit News was difficult to read. Here’s the facts. The article itself includes distressing anecdotes.

Poorer, less educated

Michigan’s exodus is one of the state’s best known but least understood problems. Long ignored or downplayed, outmigration has been shrugged off partly because it was assumed that those who were leaving were unemployed blue-collar workers and retirees, groups that, in economic terms, don’t cripple the state with their departure.

But a Detroit News analysis of U.S. Census Bureau and Internal Revenue Service data reveals that every day, Michigan gets less populated, less educated, and poorer because of outmigration.

The state’s net loss to outmigration — the number of people leaving the state minus those moving in from other states — has skyrocketed since 2001. Although the Census Bureau does not report totals moving in and out each year, Internal Revenue Service records show that the population decline is a result of two disturbing trends: The number of Michigan residents leaving the state rose 25 percent between 2001 and 2007, while the number of new residents moving in plummeted by nearly one-third.

Essentially, educated people are leaving because there’s no jobs and no future and taxation is oppressive. So those left behind are those who use most of the government services, only there’s no one to pay for those services.

The solution would to cut back services, be ruthless about budgeting and give incentives for businesses to come and work. But even if that were to happen, it would take time.

Michigan, like upstate New York, is quickly becoming an aging wasteland where there’s no jobs and those who still live there are taxed punitively.

The government doesn’t help the state with policies like these. Government interference only delays the inevitable.

What the Federal Government under President Obama want to do is not to cut services and cut spending, they want to make every state like Michigan so companies have no where to go. Redistribution of wealth and a steadily high unemployment rate, ala Europe, is just the way of life. Workers have guarantees but no one enjoys greatness.

In the socialist’s world, it’s not so bad if there’s suffering–as long as everyone is suffering. Michigan is what the President’s policies look like when played out.

Heaven forbid this happens nationwide.

  1. 5 Responses to “Mourning Michigan: Part II”

  2. Paul Gordon
    April 14 2009 / 6:48 pm
    Reply

    This has been going on for over a generation.

    Here in Houston, in the mid ’70s, the blue license plates with white lettering (Michigan) seemed to outnumber the local plates. A PBS documentary about that period noted that a MILLION people poured into Houston, looking for jobs, AND FOUND THEM.

    Instead of resenting it, I and many others here respected them because, instead of whining about their lot, they DID SOMETHING ABOUT IT by coming down here to where the jobs were.

    Pulling up stakes and leaving what you know, to start anew 1300 miles away, is damned difficult for many. Wimps don’t do that.

    Their coming here was our gain.

    -

  3. AG
    April 15 2009 / 10:28 pm
    Reply

    I’m going to be blunt. Michigan, while wonderful in the summertime, is not a very desirable place for young people to live. Our only major city is Detroit, and its been dead for years. The next biggest city is Grand Rapids, and Detroit for all its collapse is still 4 times bigger. So naturally young college grads are going to want to leave. This tendency is exacerbated by the fact that Michigan and Michigan State bring in so many out of state students that its inevitable kids are going to make friends with out of state students and when they all graduate, bolt for the nearest major city together.

  4. Frank
    April 16 2009 / 9:25 am
    Reply

    Pretty sad that so many people have to leave a state with such a beautiful vista and terrific people. We spent some of our “second” honeymoon traveling and camping in Michigan. It was a wonderful experience.

  5. Bender
    April 19 2009 / 9:34 am
    Reply

    AG — real Michiganders want nothing to do with the “big city.” That’s not the reason they leave, so they can go live in New York City or Chicago. They leave because they can see a dying state, soon to be a rotting corpse, when they see one, notwithstanding the claims of some in Ann Arbor that they are the center of the universe and therefore in a paradise.

    As the story notes, even the retirees are leaving — the auto worker retirees. And far from not crippling the state with their departure, they actually harm the state even more when GM, Ford, and Chrysler send Michigan dollars to retirees living in Florida, thereby enriching Florida and making Michigan all that much poorer.

    TO ANY FOOL STILL LIVING IN MICHIGAN — Get out! Get the hell out NOW, while there is still time, while you still may be able to get a decent price for the sale of your home. Get out NOW, you are like New Orleans and Katrina is coming! Save yourselves!

    Thank God, come this August, I will be celebrating the 20th anniversary of my exodus from that hell-hole.

  6. Garna Lee Parsley
    October 20 2009 / 3:15 pm
    Reply

    AG – I’m constantly combing the web regarding the current state of affairs in Michigan. This post is 6 months after the latest post…and I don’t have any positive news to add. My family and I permanently left Michigan Aug. 5, 2007. Since then, we have not returned. We were unable to sell our home so we rented it to indirect family. This proved to be a disaster as they had to be recently evicted. They were unable to pay the rent on-time, if at all, due to too many hardships in Michigan that every other Michiganian must endure. My mother in-law tells me stories of where there has been rioting for food, vouchers for housing assistance, job applications being taken. I don’t think it is very easy for any of the current Michigan residents to leave now. The decision for my family and myself to leave Michigan was heartbreaking and took nerves of steel. We still miss Michigan very much but will not go back to a state that is bankrupt. Unless things change up there drasticly…my family and I are alive and well in North Carolina. As to our home,…my mother is trying to take it over. We will see if this works…or it just might end up in foreclosure like everyone else.

Post a Comment

But Before You Say That…

  • Comments that are inappropriate, rude, completely stupid, or obviously meant to bait others into a flame war may be deleted.  If that happens to you and you want to throw a tantrum about “free speech,” do it on your own blog.  Basically, if you wouldn't say it to someone's face without the shield of anonymity, don't say it here.
  • If you are a new commenter or are using a new e-mail address, your comment will go to moderation.  Even regular commenters get stuck in moderation sometimes.  Please be patient; your comment will be published as soon as I can get to it.
  • Comments that will never get published are those that are posted under the name “anonymous” and those using an obviously fake e-mail address.