Flammable Pajamas Media

February 1, 2009 / 1:28 pm • By Dr. Melissa Clouthier

I can’t imagine a worse business position to be in than having to fire a bunch of bloggers. It must stink. Bloggers have a platform on which to air business grievances and for some, their stock in trade anyway is, well, grievances. Worse, I can’t imagine having to fire some of the best bloggers on the web. I can’t imagine continuing successfully being frozen out by those bloggers down the road.

Last Friday, turns out that most, if not all, Pajamas Media affiliated bloggers got the boot. Roger Simon, CEO, said that there just wasn’t enough money to continue. It’s not surprising that another business is feeling the economic pinch especially since ad dollars are scarcer than Britney Spears undies. Still, the pain it is causing is real.

Unlike others in this profession, I didn’t think PJM had a bad business model. In fact, I thought it was pretty smart. Take the best bloggers on the web, and talk to advertisers who would have their ads seen by thousands of readers across many different venues. Plus, the bloggers themselves would have money to count on so they could relax and focus on blogging.

When friends started getting the invites I watched with a mixture of jealousy and admiration. I was still a newbie though, had a young baby and a special needs child, plus for a year, homeschooling. My life was busy and my blog reflected a hectic schedule. I had no pressure. My blog posts tended to be long winded or short or whatever I felt like. At the start, it wasn’t so much about quality as it was just getting something out there and connecting to an intellectual world while stuck at home.

Other people, like Ann Althouse, were offered a position and took the moral high road. No way. No pay. Ann felt it would inhibit her independence. I didn’t think much of that argument then. I mean, who would police the bloggers? Turns out, that didn’t happen. But I respected Ann’s choice. Plus she, like my co-blogger John Hawkins made money with BlogAds, something I occasionally do myself. As Ann says, things have been slow since the election.

Pajamas leadership decides now, to turn toward TV. Now this, I don’t get. I’ve learned the hard way that video doesn’t work well with blogging. John Hawkins and I got in an argument about it. He said readers don’t watch them, they prefer transcripts. Well, that is just irritating because that means I have to transcribe which takes time and I don’t ever have enough time. So, I polled the readers and sure enough, they reinforced what John said. Due to server and bandwith constraints or just the stress of audio in the work place, people didn’t watch videos. They couldn’t.

I’m not saying videos aren’t a good idea generally. In fact, I feel like one thing that is missing on the conservative side are good, humorous short videos demonstrating leftist stupidity and/or teaching conservative principles in a funny way. Still, I’m not sure people would pay for them. Advertisers, though, might like to advertise on those…especially ones that go viral.

Anyway, times are tough all over. Writers are becoming commodities. There are a lot of great writers out there. There are no guarantees in the business.

The people who do it for fun and don’t make a living out of it might ultimately be in better shape. Ann Althouse is a lawyer. Other bloggers like Outside the Beltway’s James Joyner have talked about it before–that making money has been secondary to just saying how he feels. Plus, he has a “real” job. Now, I see that he, too, uses blogads.

The writers let go by PJM will survive. They are some of the best and brightest. I think that the bottom line is that many are artists not business people. Two different skill-sets. It helps to have both.

  1. 10 Responses to “Flammable Pajamas Media”

  2. Matt
    February 1 2009 / 2:36 pm
    Reply

    My argument against video is the same one I use against voicemail. Why would I want to sit and wait to listen for someone to get to whatever their point is when I have the option of reading it in 1/10th the time. I don’t disagree that someone producing short, high-quality clips could successfully build an audience, but that’s not what PJM is doing with their interminably long shows.

    I’ll mostly leave aside the classless way with which Simon is handling the criticism, but would point out that Blogads has run a successful advertising model for years with the noticeable difference that they aren’t burning the profits sending Joe the Plumber to Israel.

  3. Cousin Dave
    February 1 2009 / 8:44 pm
    Reply

    I think the interview segments that PJTV has done are worthwhile. But yeah, other than that, vlogging hasn’t done anything compelling, as far as I’ve seen. The time thing is definitely a concern, plus a lot of people can’t watch videos at work due to lack of bandwidth or company rules.

    The other thing that bothers me, which Matt hints at, is that the way this has all gone down has re-opened old wounds and is creating a lot of bitterness. My fear is that it will wind up unnecessarily dividing the conservative blogosphere, which is the very last thing conservatives need to have happen right now.

  4. Dr. Melissa Clouthier
    February 1 2009 / 11:52 pm
    Reply

    Cousin Dave,

    I don’t think that will be an issue, actually. People are pretty reasonable. It’s a business and businesses rework their business models all the time.

  5. J David
    February 2 2009 / 2:07 pm
    Reply

    I do not have the computer guts to watch vids, and I skim vast quantities news/opinion while I simultaneously listen to talk radio and watch market TV. Vids sucking power to take forever to get to salient points distracts from my intake. I can’t afford, and don’t need upgrades, so I never watch them. I’m missing so little I am not concerned about it.

  6. Big Al
    February 2 2009 / 4:37 pm
    Reply

    Old saying: Why do for others what you can do for yourself? Moderized, that translates to banding together and doing what they did, but for themselves instead of PJM.

    I’ve never made a dime from blogging, not that I’d be adverse to it. I don’t have the consistancy and the readership that comes with it to generate much if any income. I blog to get whats in my head out, and if nobody reads what I write, so be it. Can’t spell worth a flip anyway…

    My main trouble is with getting what I want to talk about down before something else comes along and gets my attention off somewhere else. I’d hate to depend on it for a living, that’s for sure. But others seem to be able to constantly stream thoughs and ideas out to us (Melissa Clouthier for one), and I greatly admire that. Many bloggers in the PJM network amaze me with the speed of getting really good stuff out to the masses, and I’m sure that will be missed, but most all I’d guess are gonna keep right on typing away, so my bet is the majority will still get presented together in some format (hint hint John).

    The world, especially the cyber world, constantly changes. Sometimes for good, sometimes for the bad.

  7. John Moore
    February 2 2009 / 10:14 pm
    Reply

    Like many, I don’t have the time to listen to an interview on TV. Give me the edited down guts of it, or forget it. At least don’t charge me $23/mo to get it!

    Your suggestion about short humorous video is great, though. I’m sure there’s a market for good conservative humor (you can find some on Breightbat’s new blow – Big Hollywood ).

    I sure wish PJM had tried something creative like that, and had dipped their toes in the water before creating their over-priced, certain to be underwatched, talking heads network.

    At least Joe The Plumber was shot on site, with movement and interaction and scenery and, well, Joe!

  8. John Moore
    February 2 2009 / 10:15 pm
    Reply

    so much for not previewing. Oops.

  1. 3 Trackback(s)

  2. Feb 1, 2009: Goldfish And Clowns » Blog Archive » Blogging Evangel Redux
  3. Feb 1, 2009: The Enlightened Redneck » Pajamas Media Dumps Bloggers
  4. Feb 2, 2009: Did Joe the Plumber Kill Pajamas Media? « NotionsCapital

Post a Comment

But Before You Say That…

  • Comments that are inappropriate, rude, completely stupid, or obviously meant to bait others into a flame war may be deleted.  If that happens to you and you want to throw a tantrum about “free speech,” do it on your own blog.  Basically, if you wouldn't say it to someone's face without the shield of anonymity, don't say it here.
  • If you are a new commenter or are using a new e-mail address, your comment will go to moderation.  Even regular commenters get stuck in moderation sometimes.  Please be patient; your comment will be published as soon as I can get to it.
  • Comments that will never get published are those that are posted under the name “anonymous” and those using an obviously fake e-mail address.