The Post Wherein I Explain Myself
October 29, 2008 / 12:33 am • By Dr. Melissa ClouthierMore than one friend, both blogger and non-political observers, have warned me that my credibility will be dirt should I hold to the delusion that McCain can pull this election out. My response has been to say, “Shut up and vote. It’s over when it’s over.”
In 2006, I’ll admit it: I didn’t want to see the writing on the wall. The Congressional races were going to be bloodbaths. Republicans were going to lose big. It was obvious and I didn’t want to see it.
John Hawkins, who has been scary-good at predicting these things tells me I’m smoking the hopeful, delusional dope once again. But I’m not. Not this time. This time, I see this and I know the election outcome does not look good for McCain. I read this and I know the Obama strategy is working. I watch the Republican elites bail and I know that they believe it’s over. I note that press is actively working (with a few fair exceptions) to get Obama elected with even the LA Times withholding reporting that might make Obama look bad.
So I see all this and I see that McCain is still within reach and I refuse to be part of the chorus of malcontents adding a nail to the coffin–when there’s no one filling it. As I said earlier today, I believe that there are good reasons people might lie to pollsters about who they are voting for in this election. And then there is the whole lying with statistics thing.
Most of all though, I refuse, REFUSE, to give momentum to a candidate who will promote failed ideologies. In this charged, biased environment, I am not sure what and who to believe and I read this stuff all the time. I’m not sure how much the hype has created this outcome or if the outcome is even created. How do polls swing 8 points in a day when the external environment has barely changed? How do polls that were so extreme a week ago, tighten so dramatically? Why should I believe a word from the media driven polls when they have such a vested interest in the outcome? And I remember it being “over” in 2000 and 2004, too. Hawkins says the internals of the polls and the states swinging were much different. Maybe. Like I said: I’ll admit it. It looks really bad.
It is not, however, impossible. And it is not over.
So this time, I’m not ignoring reality, I’m hoping that reality will change. I’m hoping that volunteers in swing states can change hearts and minds. I’m hoping the McCain campaign will work hard and get a message out that I hope will inspire voters to change their apathetic ways and get out and vote.
Barack Obama, his supporters and the media have given his ascendancy an air of inevitability. You know, everyone wants to be on the side of a winner–especially those not ideologically driven. So, when America was losing the war, it was unpopular. When the war looks won, suddenly everyone supports it. Well, the same thing happens in elections and Obama and the press knows it. There will be grandiose journalistic self-examination after Obama wins. Before then, there’s a job to do and that’s to promote a winner and be on the side of the trendy and new.
I won’t participate in a self-fulfilling prophecy. I just won’t. Those like Peggy Noonan who have aired their concerns could wait ten days to give their constructive criticism, but one suspects their are personal considerations to attend to. Goodness knows that no matter the outcome of this election, the Republicans need to take a long, hard look at their tent. It’s a big tent, but it needs some cleaning up.
That can wait. For the next seven days, I write like we’re winning. I see reality clearly. It’s a long shot. Very long. And still, a McCain win is possible. As long as a win is possible, there will be no hedging or quibbling or criticizing or throwing in the towel. Well, not from me, anyway.
Cross-posted at RightWingNews.com











11 Responses to “The Post Wherein I Explain Myself”
October 29 2008 / 2:18 am
Reply
I admire your attitude and conviction. I am one of the still undecided voters, and I definitely agree with you that the press has not been fair in covering both campaigns. Keep up the good fight, and you might be able to convince more people like me.
October 29 2008 / 4:58 am
Reply
Matt, do you work? Do you feel you earn every single dollar you are paid? Who do you think knows best what to do with the money you work hard to take home, you or someone else? If you think someone else, then please start sending me $100 out of every paycheck. If you think you are the best judge of what to do with your hard earned money, then poke around the Web for IRS statistics on who pays what, particularly the percentage of people who pay effectively $0 in taxes after all the tax credits. Now reconcile that with Obama’s stated “tax cut for 95% of Americans”. I can’t make the math work. If his statement was “tax cut for 95% of the Americans who actually pay tax” it may be different. Foreign policy, poke around for recent statements by Mr Sarkozy of France on stated positions with respect to Iran.
Is McCain perfect? Hell no, far from it. But to me this election is coming down (again) to the lesser of two evils, and I think that for the long term vitality of this country, I see McCain as better choice (think judicial appointments).
But regardless who wins, it is more important to ride herd on Congress; the majority of the bozos in DC seem to think that your hard earned money is theirs and frankly, that pisses me off because I work hard for it.
October 29 2008 / 7:00 am
Reply
Just had to say that due to your delusional thoughts that McCain can win and your primary thoughts that he SHOULD win – have lost you one reader…. Me.
October 29 2008 / 8:41 am
Reply
Just flat don’t know how ANYONE who can read could be “undecided” at this point in the process. You “UNDECIDEDS” are like the people in the check-out line in the grocery store who watch the clerk ring up a couple hundred dollars of groceries and, only when given the total do you 1) get a suprised look on your face and 2) start looking for the checkbook in your purse (pocket).
You are not undecided you are CLUELESS ! ! You are in the way !
Granted, this is a race between a guy who CANNOT tell the truth and a guy who WON’T tell the truth. But, that is all the more reason to be informed about your decision.
October 29 2008 / 9:32 am
Reply
I’ll tell you what. Normally, I’d say you were smoking dope.
But this thing is almost writing itself as a DEWEY WINS headline. The press is so cocky and overconfident, the left is exposing themselves so early as scoundrels, McCain may yet surprise.
So…you’re not alone. And in 2006 I knew we were toast.
October 29 2008 / 11:47 am
Reply
If anyone wins, it will be Palin!
I would be voting Constitutional party but since they did not get listed due to 2 party restrictions, I guess I’ll vote libertarian. It won’t matter in my state as Palin will easily carry it 2 to 1.
October 29 2008 / 3:08 pm
Reply
Amen, Melissa! Thank you for not adding to the media’s attempt to doom & gloom us into submission. I totally don’t understand why rightwing blogs can’t manage to wait a week to start with tearing down the RNC and lamenting an Obama administration. It ain’t over ’til it’s over!!! If we lose, we lose, but I’m sure as heck not giving in beforehand. That, to me, isn’t foolishness, it’s courage. God is bigger than the MSM and the DNC, and I say it’s a time to pray, not write post-mortems. As Aragorn says in LOTR3, “This day we fight!”
October 29 2008 / 4:49 pm
Reply
Outstanding clarity and admirable principle.
Shame on quitters.
Shame especially on “Wendy” for her inconsistency and intolerance. Wendy is angry you WANT McCain to win? OK. But she is also angry you for thinking he CAN win?
By her reasoning, and that of the ship-jumpers, it’s over well before Election day. It’s over, in fact, right after the very first poll.
October 30 2008 / 12:33 am
Reply
Hello Mer,
Yes, I do work and I do agree with your points. I know there are more than 40% of people who don’t pay any tax at all and it’s sad to see what the congress are doing with our money. But do you really have faith that McCain will do better? I didn’t see him coming out against the bailout, and what about all those earmarks in the bailout? To be honest, I rather see my money go to a homeless person than the AIG executives.
At the end, maybe the prospect of a Democratic President and a Democratic Congress would be scary enough for me to go the other way. We need some checks and balances.
October 30 2008 / 1:33 am
Reply
Matt, I’m not going to disagree with you on the bailout, I’m not a financial guy so I don’t “know” if something needed to be done (gut feeling says maybe, but along the lines of what the FDIC/Fed is doing with insuring some of the interbank lending). McCain “do better”? Maybe “not as bad” is a better way to say it, that’s also why I said we have to ride herd on Congress. Earmarks in the bailout bill, I haven’t looked, but I’d like to see whose earmarks they are; I agree about the AIG execs.
Hope and Change: If “The One” wins, I hope to have enough change left in my pocket to buy a cup of coffe once a month.
October 30 2008 / 9:28 am
Reply
“Just had to say that due to your delusional thoughts that McCain can win and your primary thoughts that he SHOULD win – have lost you one reader…. Me.”
You’re stopping reading the blog because Dr. Clouthier has a difference of opinion with you?
Wow.
Personally I think McCain is toast, but to each their own. (I won’t stop reading this blog because you believe different than I, just sayin)