False Rape Accusations
November 30, 2006 / 9:08 pm • By Dr. Melissa ClouthierThankfully, the blogosphere exists. Why? Because where the MSM lacks the will, intellect, curiosity, open-mindedness, fairness, time and money to honestly investigate truly important cases, a multitude of individuals have all these traits and more. Such is the Duke Rape Case.
With a corrupt DA, a complicit local media and a callous Duke campus, three young men would be sent down the river (and they still might, heaven forbid) with no advocates whatsoever. Instead, sites like LieStoppers are doing a huge service to keep this information front and center.
Why do I think this case is so important? Well it’s about race, true. It’s about class, true. It’s about sex, true. It’s about feminism, true. But what it’s really about is justice or lack thereof because of all of the above social factors together.
Rape, next to murder, is one of the most heinous crimes. Brutality in the sexual form has such far-reaching consequences to the victim. It can truly be said that a woman’s life is never the same after the experience. Her sex life, her self-view, her societal view all get changed in an instant. This affects her relationships. This affects how she teaches her children about the world. It is a soul-stealing crime from which some people never recover.
When a woman falsely accuses a man of this crime, it is doubly horrendous. She knows the societal implications. She knows that rapists and sexual predators are viewed with more scorn than murderers. Her intent is to do great harm to a person’s reputation and she knows that the likelihood of the man ever getting his name back is almost nil. That’s one reason false accusations are so bad. The other reason it’s horrendous is the damage done to all women who might face this crime. Lying, vindictive women injure not just the wrongly accused man, but also women trying to muster the courage to bring such a difficult charge to light.
The Duke Rape case is so without merit and such a miscarriage of justice, it should cause every single one of us to sit up and pay attention. The consequences of this case are enormous. Three men have their very lives hanging in the balance when it should all just be over. And yet, because of jealousy, racial vendettas, and prosecutorial malfeasance, the case marches on.
When a woman is raped, she is rendered compliant because to fight often means the threat of death. It’s the helplessness, the violence and the invasion that damage her. And here these men wait–helpless, rendered compliant and experiencing violence and invasion.
Injustice for one of us is injustice for all of us. This case must be dropped.






